The Old Colonial sterling silver flatware set by Towle Silversmiths has become a sought-after collectible, with individual pieces selling for anywhere from $15 to $5,000, depending on rarity and condition. Produced between 1895 and 2009, the line was crafted from .925 sterling silver and remains one of the brand’s most iconic designs. The composition of .925 sterling—meaning 92.5% pure silver blended with 7.5% other metals, typically copper—ensures durability while maintaining the metal’s lustrous sheen. This alloy was chosen not only for its aesthetic appeal but also for its resistance to bending and wear, a critical factor in flatware intended for daily use or special occasions.
The longevity of the Old Colonial line spans more than a century, a sign to its timeless design and the brand’s commitment to quality. During its production run, Towle introduced subtle variations in the pattern, such as minor adjustments to the beading along the edges or the curvature of the scrolled tips, which can help collectors date specific pieces. Some of the rarest items in the collection include serving pieces like fish servers, grape shears, and berry spoons, which were produced in smaller quantities than standard place settings. These specialized utensils often feature more detailed detailing, such as hand-engraved floral motifs or reinforced joints to withstand heavier use.
Why collectors are hunting for these pieces
The Old Colonial collection stands out for its mirrored finish, beaded accents, and subtle scrolled tips. Unlike mass-produced flatware, each piece reflects the brand’s nearly 350-year history—Towle Silversmiths began in 1690 in Newburyport, Massachusetts, decades before the U.S. existed. The company’s origins trace back to a time when silversmithing was a revered trade, requiring apprenticeships that could last a decade. Towle’s early work included creating silver coins for the Massachusetts Bay Colony, a role that established its reputation for precision and artistry. By the time the Old Colonial line debuted in 1895, the company had already weathered economic shifts, including the Industrial Revolution, which transformed handcrafted goods into factory-produced items. Despite these changes, Towle maintained its dedication to traditional techniques, such as hand-forging and chasing, which lent each piece a unique character.
Though the company still operates under Lifetime Brands, the Old Colonial line is no longer in production, adding to its exclusivity. The discontinuation in 2009 marked the end of an era for collectors, as no new pieces would enter the market. This scarcity has driven demand, particularly for discontinued patterns or those with limited production runs. For example, some early 20th-century pieces feature a slightly thicker gauge of silver, making them heavier and more substantial in the hand—a detail that appeals to purists. Additionally, the line’s association with American history, from its colonial roots to its use in households during key moments like the Gilded Age and post-World War II prosperity, adds a layer of cultural significance that mass-produced flatware lacks.
Collectors scour antique shops, estate sales, and online auctions like eBay for these pieces. Even tarnished items retain value, as the underlying silver content remains stable. The resale market for Old Colonial has expanded beyond traditional auction houses to include specialized forums and social media groups where enthusiasts trade tips on spotting undervalued pieces. Some collectors focus on assembling full place settings, which typically include a dinner fork, salad fork, knife, and spoon, while others seek out mismatched pieces to complete partial sets inherited from relatives. The thrill of the hunt is amplified by the unpredictability of estate sales, where a single drawer of silverware might yield a rare serving piece hidden among more common items.
Full sets command the highest prices, but single serving pieces—a ladle, asparagus server, or lettuce fork—can still fetch hundreds of dollars. The value of these items is influenced not only by their condition but also by their provenance. A piece with a documented history, such as one used in a historic hotel or owned by a notable figure, can command a premium. For instance, a gravy boat from the Old Colonial line once used in a Boston Brahmin household might sell for significantly more than an identical piece with no backstory. Similarly, pieces that retain their original packaging or come with Towle’s certification of authenticity are highly prized.
Leave a Reply