For 16 years, interior designer Sam Masters kept looking. He moved through six different apartments across Manhattan, always holding out for the right one. That kind of patience is rare in New York City real estate, where most people settle or give up. The designer finally landed what many consider a unicorn: a prewar, one-bedroom in the West Village, measuring just 420 square feet.
The unit sits on a busy corner, which means noise comes with the charm. He doesn’t fight it. “It’s really nice to just have a friend over, open the windows, and feel like you’re ‘out’ without having to go out,” he said.
That approach — embracing the city instead of blocking it out — defines how he uses the small space. The apartment is compact but functional, with original prewar details that smaller renovations often strip away. He kept the bones intact and worked around them.
Related: Boston Hotels with Great Design
Six apartments and a 16-year wait
Masters first saw the building long before he lived in it. “When I first moved to Manhattan, my friends and I went out one night and walked down Bleecker Street. It was just so alive, and I looked up at these very windows and wondered who lived there,” he said. He keeps that memory grounded. Like many longtime residents, the designer admits the neighborhood has changed. The Village, he said, has “become overrun and a little annoying.” That kind of honesty is common among New Yorkers who watched their quiet streets turn into tourist destinations.
Still, the unit was worth the wait. It’s a prewar one-bedroom in a city where those are disappearing fast. Many new buildings skip the layouts and materials that older apartments offer, making existing prewar stock increasingly valuable.
The designer didn’t just find the apartment. He found the exact windows he had looked up at years earlier. That kind of full-circle moment doesn’t happen often, even in a city of eight million people.
Related: Craft-Forward Schoolhouse Restoration Echoes Old Circus Spirit
Making 420 square feet work
Inside, the designer made choices that prioritize comfort over trendy minimalism. On the left side of the living area, he re-covered a Safavieh chair in mohair fabric by Maharam. The fabric adds texture and warmth, which matters in a small space where every surface is visible. Above a settee hangs a large charcoal drawing by Roger Jones. The artwork anchors the room without overwhelming it. In a 420-square-foot apartment, scale is everything. Too much furniture and the space feels like a storage unit. Too little and it feels like a dorm room.
He balances those extremes by choosing pieces that serve multiple purposes or simply look good enough to justify their footprint. The chair is a good example: it’s a seating option, a visual anchor, and a textural element all at once.
The reality of a long hunt
Masters treated each apartment as a step, not a failure. Each place taught him something about what he actually needed — not what he thought he wanted.
Related: Top Rated Mattress of the Year Revealed
The West Village unit isn’t perfect. It’s small, it’s noisy, and it sits on a corner that draws foot traffic at all hours. But for Masters, those tradeoffs are acceptable. The location, the prewar details, and the view from those Bleecker Street windows make up for the compromises.
In a housing market where brokers often push clients toward compromises they don’t want, his story is a reminder that patience can pay off. It just might take 16 years.
Leave a Reply